How to Give Thanks in All Circumstances When It Feels Impossible

Give thanks in all circumstances. Even this one?

That was my question as I sat across the table, listening to my husband, Reggie, quote 1 Thessalonians 5:18. I thought he was crazy, and I’m sure it showed on my face.

“You want me to thank God for dead babies?” I asked after our third consecutive miscarriage in less than a year.

Sometimes that verse gets handed to hurting people like an instruction to clean up their emotions before they come to God.

I’d learned to expect this from other well-meaning Christians, but my loving husband? To put it mildly, I didn’t understand. Thankfully, I do now.

If you dread the moment at Thanksgiving when someone says, “Let’s share what we’re thankful for,” keep reading. Reggie’s response surprised me.

he Lord Gives and Takes Away: What Job Did First

After learning that he lost all of his possessions and his children, Job got up, tore his robe, and shaved his head before falling to the ground in worship (Job 1:20). He mourned, and in his grief, Job declared,

“Naked I came from my mother’s womb,

and naked I will depart.

The Lord gave, and the Lord has taken away;

may the name of the Lord be praised.”

In all this, Job did not sin by charging God with wrongdoing.

~Job 1:21-22 (NIV)

Job’s grief wasn’t sinful.

Gratitude doesn’t mean you have to stop grieving.

Job’s loss was enormous. So was his grief. And he brought it to God with open hands. He came into the world with nothing, and he expected to leave the same way. Everything in between had been his to hold, never his to keep.

What “Give Thanks in All Circumstances” Actually Asks

After I stared incredulously at Reggie for suggesting I thank God for our miscarriages, he immediately clarified his statement.

“Not FOR them,” he stated calmly. “IN them.”

…give thanks in all circumstances; for this is God’s will for you in Christ Jesus.

~1 Thessalonians 5:18

If you haven’t noticed, I’m a “words” person. So, in that moment, that “preposition denoting (fixed) position (in place, time or state),” en in Greek, changed my understanding and, with it, my whole disposition.1

My loving husband hadn’t stopped being who I knew him to be—priest and protector of our home and my heart. He was reminding me that God was still good, that He still had plans for us to prosper, and, most importantly in this moment, that He was still present with us in our most devastating season.

God is present with us IN everything, IN all circumstances, even the heartbreaking ones. And if for no other reason, His presence was reason enough to thank Him.

Even in our most devastating season. Even in our suffering.

His presence wasn’t lost on Paul either, who earlier in this letter wrote:

Brothers and sisters, we do not want you to be uninformed about those who sleep in death, so that you do not grieve like the rest of mankind, who have no hope. ~1 Thessalonians 4:13

Paul teaches grieving believers about their hope in Christ. Later, he calls them to give thanks in all circumstances. Read together, those instructions leave room for grief and thanksgiving in the same Christian life.

Paul reminded them of their hope. Then, Reggie reminded me of ours. Now, I’m reminding you.

Grief and gratitude can sit at the same table.

We aren’t sitting alone. Jesus is at the table with us. He’s sitting at every table, in every circumstance.

…always giving thanks to God the Father for everything, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ. ~Ephesians 5:20

Over in Ephesians, Paul reaches for a different word, hyper. Hyper can mean “for the sake of” or “on behalf of.” 2 Either way, every thank-you he mentions goes to the Father in Jesus’ name. But notice what neither passage asks of us: to look at what we lost and call our suffering good. Nor do they forbid honest grief.

No, Paul’s teaching the Thessalonians and Ephesians a posture they can carry inside circumstances they didn’t choose.

What You’re Still Holding

The posture Paul’s teaching here is open hands. The spiritual practice behind it is truth. Open hands begin with an honest inventory of what they are actually holding.

What are you trying to make yourself feel grateful for when what you really need to do first is tell God the truth about it?

Perhaps you’re holding how the holidays used to look. Or perhaps you’re holding the lie that you can’t be grateful that your parents are still here and tired from caregiving. The two truths can coexist. Or you’re holding a version of yourself in a role that no longer exists. You were the strong one but didn’t realize strength is something God clothes you in.

And you’re wondering why you haven’t been able to hold these images, roles, or beliefs together by gripping harder.

The answer is in Job’s posture.

Remember, he knew he came into the world with nothing, and expected to leave with the same open hands. Intellectually, you know that, but walking in it can be difficult.

I knew that too. Then Reggie died. The man who taught me to give thanks IN all circumstances became the one I had to release. Reggie was never mine to keep. God had entrusted us to each other for a season. Letting go of people and dreams really hurts.

How to Practice Open Hands in Prayer This Week

To help me keep this posture, I approach God with open hands in prayer:

“Lord, help me be thankful IN all things.”

While praying, I include three things:

1. My body first. I pray with my palms up. I use my body as a dashboard, noticing where I’m clenched. I try to release physically, mentally, emotionally, and spiritually. Sometimes God creates space in a rebuilding life before He shows us what fills it.

2. One truth. Then, I tell God, in one sentence, what hurts.

3. One honest thanks. I conclude by naming one gift still in my hand, in this season. I do so without pretending I’m thankful for the loss.

This Thanksgiving, maybe gratitude doesn’t need to look like gripping tighter. Maybe it looks like opening your hands, telling God exactly what is in them, and receiving today’s portion from Him. Something like “God, I hoped this would happen. When it didn’t happen, it hurt. It really hurt. Show me how to steward what remains in my hands today. What do you want me to continue holding? What should I release? And help me give thanks in all circumstances as I do it.”

1Strong, J. (1995). In Enhanced Strong’s Lexicon. Woodside Bible Fellowship.

2Ibid.

Share this post:

Sign up for the Family Christian Newsletter

Inspiration & Practical Tips for Experiencing Simple Moments with Jesus

Additional Faith Articles